How to Match a Film Look with Basic Color Correction Tools

Quite possibly one of the most intimidating disciplines for any filmmaker or video producer to tackle is color grading. Yet, it’s one artform that if mastered, could play one of the most significant roles in truly setting your work apart. It’s such an important aspect of the filmmaking and video production process, that there are huge post houses dedicated just to this task. Large corporate clients, production companies and Hollywood studios can spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars on color correction and grading (also called color timing in the feature world).

ARRI Media Grading Suite Dolby Vision

The ARRI Media color grading suite (photo © Arri CC BY-SA). Luckily, with today’s tools, you don’t need a sweet suite like this to color grade your work (but hey, if you can afford it, knock yourself out!)

But what if you’re like me. You’re a lone producer (or perhaps, part of a small team of a boutique studio) and the work you do doesn’t really have any budget allocated for a dedicated colorist. What is a “jack of all trades” and “wearer of many hats” to do when one of those “hats” doesn’t fit quite right?

Well, first I want to assure you that basic color grading does not have to be as daunting as it seems. If I can do it, you can too. And today I want to show you a quick and dirty technique for color grading your film and video, and along the way, you’ll become more accustomed to the color grading tools already at your disposal.

A Word About LUTs

I would be remiss not to mention the use of LUTs and “Looks.” Many of you (like me) will most likely start your color grading session applying some sort of LUT (Lookup Table). These are pre-designed “looks” for your video that automatically adjust color, luminance, curves, etc., to help you arrive at a look you want. The purpose of this piece is to show you some color grading basics which will give you more flexibility to creating any look you want, with or without using LUTs.

Matchmaking

Have you ever seen a cool photo, or better yet, a film or video, and thought to yourself, “I wish I could color my films to look like that?” Well, for the most part, you can. Of course, a huge amount of the look of a film is created with art direction, lighting, and cinematography, but the color grade is also a powerful tool.

This exercise will illustrate one of the foundational concepts of color-correction: shot matching. Whether we’re building a stylized look based on a reference image or just trying to get different cameras to cut together, matching two shots is an essential tool of the colorist. And it’s something that cannot be done just with preset LUTs.

Before we get started you should know that I am NOT a professional colorist (nor do I play one on TV). And quite frankly, that’s kinda the point. You don’t need to be a professional colorist, or even an experienced user of color grading tools, to do this trick. I know just enough to be dangerous and to make my work look the way I want. So this will be a great exploration for those of you who want to expand your color grading skills, but are afraid to take that leap.

Special note to REAL colorists: I would LOVE it if you would chime in and lend your experience and expertise. I want this blog post to be a conversation about color.

At the end of this article is a short video tutorial using FCPX to do this trick. Feel free to jump right to that if you like. I’ll cover some additional details in the article.

La La Land vs Moonlight

I decided to use two Oscar-winning movies to perform my little experiment. I’m going to take the opening musical number from Damien Chazelle’s La La Land and match it to the opening of this year’s best picture winner Moonlight. Given what happened at the end of this year’s Oscar night, I thought it would be fun to use these two terrific films. Also, Moonlight has a very distinct look to it (one that I’m a particular fan of).

moonlight

I thought La La Land was a good starting point because most of the film is color timed to look “normal.” The colors definitely pop, and it has a rich tone, but there’s nothing about it that looks surreal or “stylized”.

lalaland before

Shooting Flat

As is usually the case when it comes to filmmaking, the work you do in post production starts long before you enter the editing room. When it comes to color grading, it starts with how you capture your image. There are a number of considerations to be best prepared to color grade. We’ll start with the basics.

In a perfect world you’d color grade with a flatter image than this clip from La La Land. Saturation, sharpness, and contrast all play a significant role in the color grading process. In order to have the most flexibility, experienced filmmakers shoot their footage “flat.” That is, saturation, sharpness and contrast are significantly reduced in-camera, thereby allowing you to make them look the way you want when you start the edit. When shooting with DSLRs, I used to use the custom setting popularized by famed filmmaker and colorist, Stu Maschwitz: adjusting sharpness and contrast all the way down, and two notches down on saturation.

image2

Image copyright Stu Maschwitz.

I currently shoot with a Panasonic GH4 and the Blackmagic 4k Production Camera, and for the latter is use the Cinestyle profile and I shoot in the “Film” dynamic range setting on the BM4KPC.

When shooting flat, the image you capture will essentially look lifeless. However, shooting flat will give you the most latitude when making color enhancements in post.

A Colorful Parade

The ultimate goal of this exercise is simple, and so we will use a simple tool to adjust the Red, Green, and Blue channels for the La La Land clip to match as closely as those channels on the Moonlight clip. To do that, I’m going to use the RGB Parade.

Whenever color grading, it’s important, dare I say essential, to use scopes. These are built-in “monitors” of your NLE designed to show you the luminance and color values of your image. The three most popular scopes are the Histogram, Vectorscope, and Waveform. For purposes of this tutorial, I’m going to use the Waveform monitor and specifically the RGB parade.

The waveform monitor displays the luminance values of your image on an IRE scale, from about 120 to -20 (with 100 being pure white and 0 being black). The RGB parade splits the light into the three primary color (Red, Green, and Blue) and displays them horizontally next to each other. Here is the RGB Parade for La La Land before we make the change:

lalaland before

And here’s the RGB parade for the Moonlight clip.

moonlight 1

Now this is where we get down and dirty. As I mentioned earlier, our goal is to adjust the individual RGB values for the La La Land clip. To do that we need to apply a curves filter. Most major NLEs will have such a feature built-in (like Premiere Pro, DaVinci Resolve, Media Composer) or if you’re using Final Cut Pro X, you can use any number for plugins and filters available in the FCPX ecosystem. In the past I’ve frequently used Nattress Curves (available through FXFactory). But lately, my go-to color grading tool set has been Color Finale by Denver Riddle of Color Grading Central. It’s a whole set of color grading tools accessible directly within FCPX, including Vectors, Curves, Color Wheels and LUTs. For this assignment, I applied the Curves.

lalaland curves before

The curves filter from Color Finale in FCPX.

Now all we have to do is adjust the red, green, and blue values on the curves so that the RGB parade for La La Land matches as closely as possible to that of Moonlight.

Since I cannot have the two RGB parades up on my scopes at the same time, I took a screenshot of the Moonlight RGB parade and positioned next to my waveform monitor with the La La Land clip up. [EDITOR’S NOTE: Thanks to Mark Spencer of Ripple Training fame for reminding me in the comments that you CAN have two scopes open at the same time. A feature in FCPX I totally forgot. Use the CTRL-CMD-3 (or from the menu, Window > Go to > Event Viewer) and open the Event Viewer. Then turn on the scopes for the source clip. See, that’s why it’s good to make these posts a “conversation.” Thanks Mark.]

fcpx gradewindow

For each color, I grab the line near the whites (towards the top) and the blacks (towards the bottom), and adjust accordingly. I can even place multiple nodal points along the lines for multiple adjustments to the curve.

lalaland curves after

To get the values as close to the Moonlight clip as possible, I did the following:

  • I brought up the red black and toe levels (the “toe” represents that part of the curve between the blacks and the mids);
  • I brought up the red “knee” level (the area of the curve between the mids and the whites)
  • I raised the blacks, mids, and knee of the green channel while bringing down the whites
  • And for the blue channel, I raised the blacks and lowered the whites.

Watch the video to see the adjustments in real time:

The resulting RGB parade and image for the La La Land clip is as follows:

 

lalaland after

And here’s the the Moonlight clip for comparison:

moonlight 1

Are are the two RGB parades side by side (Moonlight on the left).

Don’t expect the two waveform monitors to be identical. The distribution and variety of color in each clip will affect how the parade turns out. (Damien Chazelle and his cinematographer Linus Sandgren used a lot of primary colors, particularly in the two first big opening musical numbers.) But, as you can see from the results, I was still able to give the La La Land clip that bright, slightly nostalgic, slightly washed out grade reminiscent of Moonlight’s opening.

If you’ve been hesitant to dive into color grading because it has looked too daunting a task; if you’ve relegated your grading tasks to simple adjustments in built-in color wheels (or color boards, as the case might be), give this trick a shot.

For those of you who do this for a living, what other tips can you give? And for those of you like me who know just enough to be dangerous, what have been some of your best revelations?

In the meantime, check out the video below for the real-time tutorial:

[Editor’s note: some people have interpreted this post to suggest that you don’t need to hire a pro colorist, or that basic curves is all you need to be a pro. That is absolutely not the spirit or intent of this article. There is obviously much more to the craft than that. It’s meant to give those of us out there who might otherwise be intimidated, the courage to dip their toe into what is a fantastic art form.]

  • leokel

    Nice blog
    But rather than use a screenshot, you can do the following to grade side-by-side:
    Drag a still of the image you want into FCPX and put it on the layer above your clip.
    Shrink both the target clip and the one you’re copying to 50% and reposition them side-by-side.
    Add Color Finale to the graded clip and get going – that way you can switch between the various scopes and compare your work using CMD-V to switch each one on and off.
    NB this technique is suggested by Denver Riddle as part of his Color Finale masterclass – it’s a good investment if you plan to use CF as he’s really thought through ways to get the most out of it.

    • Thanks for the tip Leokel. I think you mean just hit “V” to turn each clip on and off, correct?

      • leokel

        Yes. Sorry. Stupid typo.

    • I think by doing Mark’s tip above, you don’t need to do this. Correct?

  • markspencer

    Or you can open your first clip in the Event Viewer and really have both clips and both set of scopes side by side.

    • Ah. Of course. I never use that feature. I totally forgot about that. I just may need to update the video to show that. Thanks Mark!

    • Thanks Mark. I added an editor’s note to the post.